What religion should i choose?

I was raised as an atheist but recently I found god while tending my garden the other day. I had a spiritual moment and now i've decided to devote the rest of my life to a religion. So I did some research but to my surprise i found that there were hundreds of monotheistic religions to choose from. At first I thought: "big deal-- i'll just choose one of them and the god has got to be one for all--right?" But then i did some more research and found some inconsistencies between almost all religions. At this point I just want to go to heaven. But how do i make the right choice? jews tell me to reject christ; cristians tell me to accept him as holy. Ala's kingdom is different from the christian god's kingdom. Im so confused!! is there more than one kingdom, a heaven for each religion? Every thing is just so inconsistent and i am confused and afraid. very VERY afraid. I don't want to burn in hell for all eternity. I also did some demographic research and found out that a very large majority of the world is destined to burn in hell for all eternity because they will in all likelihood have chosen the wrong religion. This is starting to seem like guesswork to me. can someone please guide me?